Five Best Pizza Recipes for Home Cooks

Follow each recipe’s target temperature rather than automatically turning the oven to maximum—different doughs are designed for different kinds of heat.

Classic Margherita Pizza

Tomatoes, mozzarella, basil, olive oil, and dough leave nowhere for weak ingredients—or weak technique—to hide. That is precisely why a Margherita is the ideal first pizza. It teaches the cook how quickly the crust colors, how often it needs to be turned, and how much moisture the oven can handle.

Ooni’s Classic Margherita is clear, restrained, and designed for a high-temperature pizza oven. Use good canned tomatoes, drain very wet fresh mozzarella, and resist the temptation to overload the center. A lighter hand produces a crisper base and a more dramatic rim.

BEST OVEN MATCH: Gozney Arc XL, Solo Stove Pi Prime, or any oven capable of maintaining roughly 750°F to 850°F

WHY MAKE IT: It is the purest test of dough, heat, and timing

New York-Style Cheese Pizza

The best New York pizza is crisp underneath, tender enough to fold, and sturdy enough to hold sauce and cheese without collapsing. It needs less ferocious heat and more baking time than Neapolitan pizza, which makes temperature control particularly important.

J. Kenji López-Alt’s New York–Style Pizza for Serious Eats uses a food processor to build the dough efficiently and adds oil and sugar for tenderness, browning, and the characteristic longer bake. It is an excellent project for anyone who wants to understand why New York dough is not simply Neapolitan dough cooked at a lower temperature.

BEST OVEN MATCH: Ooni Koda 2 Max, whose 20-inch capacity and independent burners are unusually well suited to a full-size pie

WHY MAKE IT: This is the recipe that makes the Koda 2 Max feel like a neighborhood pizzeria

Pizza-Oven Detroit Pizza

Detroit pizza reverses several assumptions about “serious” pizza. It is thick rather than thin, rectangular rather than round, and defined by the almost-black frico of cheese that caramelizes against the edge of its metal pan.

King Arthur Baking’s Pizza-Oven Detroit Pizza is specifically adapted for countertop pizza ovens. That distinction matters: a recipe written for a 500°F kitchen oven can burn before its center is cooked when transferred without adjustment to an 800°F machine. Use a proper dark Detroit pan if possible, and spread the cheese all the way to the perimeter to create the signature crisp edge.

BEST OVEN MATCH: Breville Smart Oven Pizzaiolo, Ooni Koda 2 Max on a lower setting, or Alfa Moderno 2 Pizze

WHY MAKE IT: It demonstrates that a pizza oven can do far more than thin, fast-baked pies

New York-Style White Pizza

A white pie replaces tomato sauce with a rich but balanced combination of cheeses, garlic, herbs, and olive oil. The absence of tomato makes the quality of the crust especially noticeable, while ricotta provides creamy contrast to the browned mozzarella.

Serious Eats’ New York–Style White Pizza layers ricotta, mozzarella, and Parmesan with garlic, thyme, and parsley. It is sophisticated enough for guests but built from ingredients readily available at a good supermarket. Watch the underside carefully: without a wet layer of tomato sauce, the crust can brown faster.

BEST OVEN MATCH: Gozney Arc XL or Breville Smart Oven Pizzaiolo

WHY MAKE IT: It is elegant, meatless, and a useful change from red sauce

Soppressata Pizza With Calabrian Chiles and Hot Honey

This is the contemporary crowd-pleaser: salty cured meat, fruity chile heat, melted cheese, and a finishing drizzle of sweetness. Hot honey has become ubiquitous because the combination works, but Calabrian chiles keep the pizza from tasting like a novelty.

Food & Wine’s Soppressata Pizza With Calabrian Chiles and Hot Honey is the one to serve after you have mastered launching and turning. Allow the dough to lose its refrigerator chill before shaping, distribute the soppressata rather than blanketing the pizza, and add the honey with restraint.

BEST OVEN MATCH: Gozney Arc XL, Solo Stove Pi Prime, or Alfa Moderno 2 Pizze

WHY MAKE IT: It delivers the sweet-hot, deeply savory flavor people expect from a fashionable modern pizzeria

• See our Five Best Pizza Ovens for Home Cooks

• Explore the PMC Store for our curated selection of luxury gifts

PoliticsMoneyCulture and Jasper & James may earn a commission from purchases made through selected links, at no additional cost to you. Recommendations are independently selected.

Click here to explore the full PMC Shop.